We independently choose the products in this guide. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. How we make money.

Key takeaways

  • Yogurt makers keep milk at about 110°F (43°C) for 6–12 hours so the cultures can work.
  • Best overall: Instant Pot Duo (yogurt setting). Best dedicated maker: Euro Cuisine YM80. Best strainer: Euro Cuisine GY50.
  • Strain plain yogurt for thick, high-protein Greek yogurt: a 170 g pot of nonfat Greek yogurt has about 17 g protein (USDA).
  • Homemade means no added sugar unless you add it.

Greek yogurt is one of the best high-protein foods you can eat, and one of the more expensive ones to buy in single cups. Making it yourself costs far less, tastes fresher and lets you skip the added sugar in many flavored yogurts. Yogurt makers and strainers make the process almost foolproof. Here are the best, plus a simple method.

Why make yogurt at home?

From above crop faceless male eating organic white yogurt from glass jar by using bamboo spoon
Photo: Cats Coming on Pexels
  • Cost: a gallon of milk makes a gallon of plain yogurt.
  • Control: no added sugar, thickeners or flavors unless you choose them. See hidden sugar foods for why it matters.
  • Protein: strained Greek yogurt is a protein powerhouse, perfect for breakfasts and snacks. See high-protein breakfast ideas.
  • Live cultures: fresh yogurt is a fermented food. Learn more in our fermented foods list.
Homemade yogurt in 5 steps: chart from the article “The 6 Best Yogurt Makers and Greek Yogurt Strainers”
Etekcity Food Scale
⚖️ Amazon Best Seller
Etekcity Food Scale

0.1g accuracy — the perfect companion for exact portions.

The best yogurt makers and strainers

1. Instant Pot Duo 7-in-1: best overall

If you’re going to buy one appliance, a multicooker with a yogurt setting does it all: it can boil the milk and then hold it at the right temperature to incubate. It also pressure cooks, slow cooks and makes rice. See our slow cooker and multicooker guide.

Check price on Amazon Instant Pot Duo 7-in-1 Electric Pressure Cooker 6 Quart

2. Euro Cuisine YM80: best dedicated yogurt maker

The YM80 holds seven glass jars at a steady temperature, so you get individual portions ready to grab. It’s simple and affordable.

Check price on Amazon Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker

3. Cuisinart CYM-100 Electronic Yogurt Maker: best automatic

Cuisinart’s yogurt maker includes an automatic cooling function that switches to refrigeration when incubation ends, so yogurt doesn’t over-ferment if you’re asleep or at work.

Check price on Amazon Cuisinart CYM-100 Electronic Yogurt Maker

4. Euro Cuisine GY50 Greek Yogurt Maker: best strainer

Delicious yogurt bowl topped with fresh kiwi, cashews, and mixed berries, perfect for a healthy breakfast.
Photo: Antoni Shkraba on Pexels

A fine mesh strainer inside a container: pour in plain yogurt, refrigerate, and the whey drains away. Strain for 2 hours for creamy yogurt, or overnight for labneh-thick yogurt.

Check price on Amazon Euro Cuisine GY50 Greek Yogurt Maker

5. Cuisipro Donvier Greek Yogurt Maker: best fine-mesh strainer

A popular alternative strainer with a very fine mesh that makes thick yogurt and labneh.

Check price on Amazon Cuisipro Donvier Greek Yogurt Maker

6. Dash Greek Yogurt Maker: best compact

Dash’s compact yogurt maker comes with containers and a strainer, so you can make and strain yogurt in one kit. Good for small kitchens.

Check price on Amazon Dash Greek Yogurt Maker

Tips for the best homemade yogurt

  1. Use fresh, whole or 2% milk for creamier yogurt; skim works but is thinner.
  2. Heat to about 180°F (82°C) for a thicker texture, then cool to about 110°F (43°C).
  3. Use a fresh starter: plain store-bought yogurt with live cultures, or a freeze-dried starter.
  4. Don’t stir while it incubates.
  5. Save the whey from straining for smoothies or baking.

Healthy ways to eat homemade yogurt

Glass of strawberry yogurt parfait with granola on a wooden table, garnished with pink flowers.
Photo: Lisa Fotios on Pexels
  • Parfait: yogurt, berries and a spoon of granola or nuts.
  • Savory bowl: yogurt with cucumber, olive oil and herbs.
  • Swap for sour cream on tacos and potatoes.
  • Smoothies: add protein without powder. See our blender guide.

How to choose yogurt makers

Multicooker or dedicated yogurt maker?

If you’ll use the pressure cooker, rice and slow cook settings too, a multicooker with a yogurt function is the most versatile choice. If you want ready-to-grab single portions, a dedicated yogurt maker with individual jars, like the Euro Cuisine YM80, is simpler.

Jars or one big container?

Individual jars are great for lunch boxes and portion control. One large container is easier to strain into Greek yogurt and takes up less fridge space.

Automatic shut-off or cooling

Yogurt keeps getting tangier the longer it incubates. Yogurt makers with a timer or automatic cooling, like the Cuisinart CYM-100, stop at the right moment even if you’re away.

Greek yogurt strainers: how thick do you want it?

  • 1 to 2 hours: creamy, slightly thicker than regular yogurt.
  • 3 to 4 hours: classic Greek yogurt texture.
  • Overnight: very thick, close to labneh, perfect for spreads and dips.

Straining removes whey, which concentrates protein but also reduces volume, often by about half for Greek-style yogurt.

Homemade yogurt cost comparison

Making yogurt from a gallon of milk produces about a gallon of plain yogurt, or about half that as strained Greek yogurt, usually for much less than buying single-serve cups. Plain store-bought tubs are cheaper than cups, but homemade still tends to win. See how to eat healthy on a budget for more savings.

Yogurt makers: common mistakes

  • Adding the starter to milk that’s too hot, which kills the cultures.
  • Moving the yogurt while it sets.
  • Using flavored or sweetened yogurt as a starter. Use plain yogurt with live cultures.
  • Forgetting to save a starter from your batch for next time; a few spoonfuls work for several rounds before you need fresh.

Homemade yogurt is also a great base for gut-friendly breakfasts; see foods for gut health and prebiotic foods to pair it with.

The bottom line

Yogurt makers turn milk into fresh, low-cost yogurt with no added sugar. The Instant Pot Duo is the most versatile choice, the Euro Cuisine YM80 is the best dedicated yogurt maker, and the Euro Cuisine GY50 makes thick Greek yogurt with almost no effort. Make a batch on Sunday and you’ll have high-protein breakfasts all week.

Frequently asked questions

Is it cheaper to make your own yogurt?

Usually, yes. Yogurt made from a gallon of milk costs much less than the same amount of store-bought yogurt, especially compared with Greek yogurt in single-serve cups.

How do you make Greek yogurt at home?

Make plain yogurt, then strain it through a fine strainer or cheesecloth in the fridge for 2 to 8 hours. The liquid whey drains away, leaving thick, higher-protein yogurt.

Do I need a yogurt maker?

Not necessarily. Many multicookers, like the Instant Pot, have a yogurt setting. A dedicated yogurt maker is handy if you don't own one or want individual jars.

Is homemade yogurt healthier?

It can be, because you skip the added sugar and thickeners in many flavored yogurts. Plain yogurt you sweeten yourself with fruit is a better everyday choice.

Can I make yogurt with plant milk?

Yes, but plant milks need help to thicken. Use a plant-based starter culture, choose a milk with some protein such as soy, and some recipes add a little thickener.

How long does homemade yogurt last?

Homemade yogurt usually keeps for one to two weeks in the fridge in a clean, covered container.

Why is my homemade yogurt runny?

Common causes are incubating too short a time, a temperature that's too low, an old or weak starter, or stirring during incubation. Straining fixes runny yogurt quickly.

What milk makes the thickest yogurt?

Whole milk makes the creamiest yogurt. Adding a little dry milk powder or straining also thickens it.

Can I use an Instant Pot to make Greek yogurt?

Yes. Make plain yogurt with the yogurt setting, then strain it in the fridge for a few hours.

How much protein does homemade Greek yogurt have?

Strained Greek yogurt is similar to store-bought: about 17 g of protein in a 170 g serving of nonfat Greek yogurt, according to USDA data.

Can I make yogurt without a starter?

You need live cultures to make yogurt. Plain store-bought yogurt with live and active cultures is the easiest starter.

Is homemade yogurt safe for kids?

Yes, when made with pasteurized milk, clean equipment and stored in the fridge. Sweeten it with fruit rather than lots of sugar.

Can I freeze homemade yogurt?

Yes, though the texture may become grainy after thawing. Frozen yogurt cubes work well in smoothies.

Sources

This article is for general information and isn’t medical advice. Talk to your doctor or a registered dietitian about your own needs, especially if you have a health condition, are pregnant or take medication.